"We’ve recently uncovered some lost footage. Take a look…"
Tamara Lynn Chambers
as Dolores
Doug Walker
as Nostalgia Critic
Malcolm Ray
as Contestant #1
Brett Bonynge
as Contestant #2
Robbie Allen
as Bob
Alyssa Jackson
as Barbara
Paul Rohan
as Ben
Jimmy Melf
as Reilly
Harry Locke IV
as Julio
Jim Jarosz
as Rolly the Fox/Practitioner
Heather Reusz
as Atlantis Somerset
Nick La Banca
as Nautical Nineties Narrator
Justin Hoffman
as "Spin My Helm" Singer
McKane Searle
as "Spin My Helm" Bassist
James Banasiak
as "Spin My Helm" Drummer
Alexis Banasiak
as Waving Woman 1
Mooog
as Waving Woman 2
Rob Scallon
as Waving Man
Catheryn Kuhar
as Sailor Girl
Danny Grenchik
as "Shark Weak" Singer
Trevor Casterline
as "Poop Deck Peck" Harmony 1
Tom Reusz
as "Poop Deck Peck" Harmony 2
Aiyanna Wade
as Wife
Steve Davis
as Husband
Joe Banasiak
as Old Man
Jim Banasiak
as Skeleton
Walter Banasiak
Director
Writer
Editor
Producer
Assistant Director
Blake Labriola
Director of Photography
Production Designer
Makeup Artist
Unit Production Manager
Jake Edgar
Gaffer
Elijah K Ashburn
Sound
Second Assistant Director
Assistant Property Master
Lucas Hunter Morgan
Music
Rob Williams
Visual Effects
John Banasiak
Production Assistant
Jesse Logan
Connor Davenport
Max Dinerstein
Ted Karns
Thanks
Brad Donati
